Michael Lombardi’s Critique: Panthers Failed Bryce Young

In a recent interview with NFL Network, former general manager Michael Lombardi criticized the Carolina Panthers for their handling of rookie quarterback Bryce Young.

Lombardi’s Arguments

Lombardi argued that the Panthers had failed to provide Young with adequate support and guidance, leading to his struggles during his first season. He cited several factors:

• Lack of pass protection: Young was sacked 40 times in 17 games, severely limiting his ability to operate effectively.
• Conservative game plan: The Panthers’ offensive coordinator, Ben McAdoo, called a run-heavy game plan that limited Young’s chances to develop as a passer.
• Coaching changes: Young had three different offensive coordinators during his rookie season, which created instability and disrupted his development.

Panthers’ Perspective

The Panthers have defended their approach, arguing that they are committed to Young’s long-term development. Head coach Matt Rhule stated that:

• The high sack total was due in part to injuries on the offensive line, and they are working to improve pass protection.
• The conservative game plan was necessary to protect Young and keep the team competitive while he gained experience.
• The coaching changes were unavoidable and that Young has the talent and work ethic to overcome the challenges.

Data and Evidence

The data supports both sides of the argument. Young’s sack total was the highest among rookie quarterbacks in the NFL, and the Panthers’ offense was one of the least productive. However, it’s also true that injuries played a role in the pass protection issues, and Young showed flashes of potential when given the opportunity to pass.

Analysis

Lombardi’s criticism of the Panthers is valid. They failed to provide Young with the necessary environment to succeed during his rookie season. However, it’s also important to consider the Panthers’ perspective and recognize that they are committed to his development.

Lessons Learned

The Panthers’ experience with Young provides several lessons for other teams:

• It’s crucial to protect young quarterbacks and provide them with the necessary support to succeed.
• Developing a quarterback takes time and patience, and teams need to avoid making hasty judgments based on early struggles.
• Stability and consistency in coaching and play-calling are important for a young quarterback’s development.

Conclusion

Michael Lombardi’s critique of the Panthers’ handling of Bryce Young is a valuable reminder of the challenges facing young quarterbacks in the NFL. The Panthers have work to do, but they have the talent and resources to develop Young into a franchise quarterback. It’s a situation worth monitoring closely in the years to come.